Link copied!

United States v. Secretary of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

54 election officials and local governments urge Third Circuit appeals court to protect local authority over elections in federal voter rolls case

In 2025, the Department of Justice (DOJ) began demanding that states turn over sensitive voter information, claiming it was investigating practices for state list maintenance. After 30 states and Washington, D.C., refused, the DOJ sued and has lost every case in the district courts.

On behalf of 54 local election officials and local governments, Public Rights Project filed an amicus brief urging the Third Circuit of Appeals to affirm the dismissal of the DOJ’s case in Pennsylvania. We’ve also filed similar briefs in other courts of appeals to defend local authority in California, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, and Wisconsin.

The brief explains why courts must review expansive federal requests for sensitive election records and why DOJ’s demand for nonpublic voter rolls — without a good reason — isn’t a valid use of its record request authority. It also details the burdens these demands place on local election officials and how they are unlawful. Specifically, the brief argues that:

  • Surges in public record requests, including ones from the DOJ, place an unnecessary burden on local election officials and impede their ability to run day-to-day election administration duties. 
  • The DOJ is required to provide an adequate basis and proper purpose to demand sensitive voter data. Instead, its sweeping request amounts to a fishing expedition rather than a targeted inquiry into Pennsylvania’s list maintenance program.
  • Local election officials work hard to ensure that Pennsylvania meets its list maintenance requirements under the National Voter Registration Act and Help America Vote Act, so there is no valid basis for the DOJ’s request.

For these reasons, we urge the court to affirm the dismissal.

Read the amicus brief.

Related legal Cases

Committed to using government power for good.
View all legal Cases

Support the fight for civil rights

Threats to civil rights are growing nationwide — and our donors help make every one of our wins possible. Contribute to power our work to help local leaders defend and advance civil rights in the courtroom and beyond.